Can I claim for spoiled food when freezer breaks down?
You may be able to claim for food lost when a freezer breaks down, either through your home contents insurance, or as a “consequential loss” against the retailer if the appliance failed due to a fault covered by the Consumer Rights Act 2015 or the manufacturer’s guarantee. To have any realistic chance of success you must act quickly, save what you can, photograph everything, and keep receipts. Letting food spoil without evidence significantly weakens any claim.
When a freezer breaks down, the food inside can be worth hundreds of pounds. Whether you can claim for that loss, and from whom, depends on what caused the failure, how you respond, and what evidence you have. This guide explains your options clearly: consequential loss claims under the Consumer Rights Act, home insurance routes, and what evidence is needed to support either.
What is a consequential loss claim?
When a faulty appliance causes you additional financial loss beyond the cost of the appliance itself, that is known as a consequential loss. Food spoiled because a freezer failed due to a manufacturing defect is a classic example.
If the freezer is under the manufacturer’s guarantee, or has failed in a way that breaches the Consumer Rights Act 2015, you may have grounds to claim the value of the lost food from the retailer, in addition to seeking a repair or replacement of the appliance itself.
Read our guide on how to save food if your freezer stops working before you do anything else. The steps you take in the first few hours matter enormously, both for preserving food and for supporting any future claim.
What is your duty to minimise the loss?
This is the single most important point: you cannot simply let all the food spoil and then claim the full value. UK law requires you to take reasonable steps to reduce your loss. Failing to do so will significantly weaken, or invalidate, any claim you make.
- Transfer food to a neighbour’s or friend’s freezer if possible
- Use cool bags or boxes with ice to preserve perishables
- Cook and consume food that is still safe but beginning to defrost
- Refrigerate anything that cannot be kept frozen but is still edible
- Only dispose of food that is genuinely unsafe or beyond saving
The more you can demonstrate that you acted reasonably to minimise the loss, the stronger your position when making a claim.
What evidence do you need and why does it matter?
Claims for food loss are frequently rejected or reduced because consumers cannot demonstrate what was actually lost or prove its value. Gathering evidence immediately, before disposing of anything, is essential.
Photograph everythingTake clear photographs of the contents of the freezer before throwing anything away. Photograph individual items, open packaging, and the overall state of the freezer. These images are your primary evidence of what was lost and its approximate volume and value.
Keep receipts where possibleReceipts are extremely helpful and may be essential to prove the value of the food. Supermarket loyalty card apps often hold purchase histories. Bank and card statements showing recent food shopping can also support a claim where receipts are unavailable.
Retain packaging where safePackaged foods such as vacuum-sealed items, boxed goods, and unopened products are easier to retain as evidence than fresh food. Keep what you safely can without creating a health hazard. Photograph and then dispose of anything perishable that cannot be safely stored.
Write a detailed listAs you empty the freezer, create a written itemised list of everything discarded, including approximate quantities and estimated values. A contemporary written record is far more credible than a figure recalled weeks later when a claim is being assessed.
Do not retain food that is rotting, smelling, or poses a health or hygiene risk. Photograph it first, then dispose of it safely. No insurer or retailer will expect you to keep genuinely hazardous material as evidence.
What can you realistically claim?
Retailers and insurers will be cautious about claims for a completely full freezer of entirely spoiled food. In most cases, total loss is unlikely because freezers are opened regularly, many have temperature alarms, and a full freezer with the door kept closed can maintain safe temperatures for up to 48 hours after losing power.
Situations where total loss may be realistic
Returning from a holiday to find the freezer has been off for several days. A fault that went unnoticed while the household was away. A failure with no audible alarm and a freezer kept in a utility room or garage. In these circumstances, documenting the specific situation clearly when making your claim is important.
Where total loss claims face scrutiny
A claim for complete loss on a frequently opened freezer in daily use will be questioned. A retailer or insurer may argue that the failure should have been noticed sooner, or that more food could have been saved with reasonable action. Partial claims with clear evidence are more credible than total loss claims without it.
How do you claim against the retailer?
If the freezer failed due to a manufacturing defect, whether under guarantee or as a breach of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, the retailer is legally responsible for the appliance failure and may also be responsible for the consequential food loss it caused.
-
Get the fault professionally diagnosed. A retailer will not consider a consequential loss claim without first establishing the cause of the appliance failure. You will typically need a refrigeration engineer, ideally one authorised by the manufacturer, to confirm the fault. If the failure was caused by something other than the appliance itself (for example, a faulty wall socket), the retailer is not responsible.
-
Make a written claim to the retailer. Put your claim in writing, citing the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and stating that the freezer failure caused consequential food loss. Include your itemised list, photographs, and any available receipts. Set out clearly what you are seeking.
-
Do not accept a refusal without challenge. Retailers sometimes refuse consequential loss claims. If the underlying appliance failure is covered by your consumer rights, a consequential loss claim is legally supportable. Seek advice from Citizens Advice if a retailer refuses a valid claim. See our guide: Consumer Rights Act and faulty appliances.
What if the freezer is out of guarantee?
An expired manufacturer’s guarantee does not automatically end your rights. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, you have up to six years from the date of purchase (five years in Scotland) to make a claim against the retailer for an appliance that has failed prematurely due to an inherent fault.
The newer the appliance and the more expensive the failure, the stronger your claim is likely to be. Retailers often try to redirect consumers to the manufacturer once a guarantee has expired, but the legal obligation remains with the retailer, not the manufacturer.
See our full guide: out of guarantee does not always mean you should pay for repairs.
Should you claim on home contents insurance?
Some home contents insurance policies cover food loss from a freezer breakdown. This cover is sometimes included as standard, but is more often an optional add-on. Check your policy documents carefully.
Claiming through insurance is usually simpler than claiming against a retailer, but there are trade-offs to consider:
- Your premium may increase at renewal
- You will usually need to pay an excess, which may reduce or eliminate the payout on smaller claims
- Making a claim affects your no-claims history
- The insurer may apply limits on what they will pay per item or in total
For larger losses, insurance may still be the most practical route, particularly if the appliance failure is not covered by the Consumer Rights Act (for example, because it is very old). For smaller losses, it may not be worth claiming once the excess is taken into account.
If the appliance failure also gives you grounds for a Consumer Rights Act claim against the retailer, pursuing that route means you are not left out of pocket due to a faulty product, and does not affect your insurance record. Both routes can be explored in parallel, but you cannot be compensated twice for the same loss.
Need help with a faulty freezer?
Whether you need an engineer to diagnose the fault, spare parts, or guidance on your rights, Whitegoods Help can point you in the right direction.
Frequently asked questions about claiming for spoiled freezer food
Can I claim for food lost when my freezer breaks down?
Yes, in some circumstances. If the freezer failed due to a manufacturing defect covered by the Consumer Rights Act 2015 or a manufacturer’s guarantee, you may be able to claim the value of lost food as a consequential loss from the retailer. You can also check whether your home contents insurance covers freezer food loss. In either case, you must be able to demonstrate what was lost and show that you took reasonable steps to minimise the damage.
Who do I claim against – the retailer or the manufacturer?
Your legal claim under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 is always with the retailer who sold you the appliance, not the manufacturer. The manufacturer’s guarantee runs separately and can be claimed against directly during the guarantee period, but your statutory rights sit with the retailer. Do not be redirected to the manufacturer as a substitute for the retailer’s legal obligations. See our guide: Consumer Rights Act and faulty appliances.
What evidence do I need to make a claim?
At minimum: photographs of the freezer contents before disposal, an itemised written list of what was lost with estimated values, and receipts where available. Bank and card statements showing recent grocery purchases can support your claim where receipts are missing. You will also need an engineer’s report confirming the cause of the appliance failure before most retailers will consider a consequential loss claim.
My freezer is out of its guarantee. Can I still claim?
Possibly. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, you have up to six years (five in Scotland) to bring a claim against the retailer for a freezer that has failed prematurely due to an inherent fault. The newer and more expensive the appliance, the stronger your case. An expired manufacturer’s guarantee does not end your statutory rights. Read more: out of guarantee does not always mean you should pay.
How long does a freezer keep food frozen after it stops working?
A full freezer with the door kept closed can maintain safe temperatures for approximately 48 hours after losing power. A half-full freezer typically keeps food safe for around 24 hours. Opening the door accelerates temperature loss significantly. If you discover the failure early, keep the door closed and transfer contents as quickly as possible to another freezer or cool storage. See our guide: how to save food if your freezer stops working.
Is it worth claiming on home insurance for food loss?
It depends on the value of the loss and the terms of your policy. If your policy includes freezer food cover, claiming is usually simpler than pursuing a retailer. However, you will typically pay an excess, and a claim may increase your future premiums. For smaller losses the excess alone may make a claim uneconomical. If you also have grounds for a Consumer Rights Act claim against the retailer, that route does not affect your insurance record and may be preferable.
How long do I have to make a consequential loss claim?
The Limitation Act 1980 sets the general contract claim limitation period at six years in England, Wales and Northern Ireland (five years in Scotland). In practice you should make any consequential loss claim as soon as possible after the event. Retailers and insurers are far more receptive to claims made promptly, with fresh evidence, than to claims made months later. Acting within weeks of the failure, not months, is the realistic working timeframe regardless of the longer statutory limitation period.
Should you register the guarantee?
Always register a new appliance. Failing to do so can invalidate any guarantee beyond the first 12 months, and – more importantly – means safety recall notices may never reach you. Registration is the primary way manufacturers contact owners when a dangerous fault is discovered.
Registering a new appliance is not compulsory – the standard 12-month manufacturer’s guarantee applies whether or not the appliance is registered. However, there are two important reasons to register it anyway, and both are worth taking seriously.
Two Good Reasons to Register Every Appliance
Reason 1 – Extended guarantees may require registration
Appliances always include at least a 12-month manufacturer’s guarantee. However, some come with two, five, or even ten-year guarantees. These longer guarantees are usually conditional on registering the appliance. If registration is not completed, the manufacturer may refuse to carry out free repairs once the first 12 months have elapsed – even if the appliance is within the stated guarantee period.
Statutory rights under consumer law still apply regardless of whether the appliance is registered. If an appliance has an inherent fault or fails to last a reasonable time, there is still recourse under the Consumer Rights Act – but this may require effort and advice to enforce. See: consumer rights and faulty appliances.
Reason 2 – Safety recalls cannot reach unregistered owners
When a manufacturer discovers a serious safety fault with an appliance – a fire risk, an electrical fault, a gas leak risk – the first action is to contact every customer known to own the affected model. This is done through the guarantee registration database.
Beyond that, the only options available are press advertisements and public announcements, which many owners will never see. An unregistered owner may have a dangerous appliance in their home and never know about it. Serious safety issues are discovered more often than most people would expect – sometimes many years after the appliance was sold.
Fire risks, electrical faults, and gas hazards have been discovered in appliances years after sale. Without registration, there is no reliable way for the manufacturer to notify owners of affected models. See the full list of known notices: appliance safety notices.
How to Register an Appliance
Registration can usually be completed online through the manufacturer’s website, or by sending in the paper guarantee registration card included with the appliance. Online registration is quicker and provides confirmation that the registration has been received. Both methods achieve the same result – the appliance is linked to the owner’s contact details in the manufacturer’s database.
Even for appliances purchased second-hand, it is worth contacting the manufacturer to update the registration details where possible.
Consumer Rights Act and faulty appliances – All appliance safety notices
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to register my appliance to get the guarantee?
The standard 12-month manufacturer’s guarantee applies whether or not the appliance is registered. However, longer guarantees – two, five, or ten years – are often conditional on registration. Failing to register may mean the manufacturer refuses free repairs once the first year has elapsed, even if the appliance is within the stated guarantee period.
What happens if I don’t register my appliance?
Beyond potentially losing an extended guarantee, the main risk is missing safety recall notifications. When a serious fault is discovered – such as a fire or electrical risk – manufacturers contact registered owners directly. Unregistered owners have no reliable way of being informed and may continue using a dangerous appliance without knowing it. See: appliance safety notices.
Am I still protected by consumer law if I don’t register?
Yes. Statutory rights under the Consumer Rights Act apply regardless of whether an appliance is registered or not. If an appliance has an inherent fault or fails to last a reasonable time, there is still legal recourse. However, enforcing these rights may require more effort than simply making a guarantee claim. See: consumer rights and faulty appliances.
Should I buy washing machine extended warranty?
Extended warranties on washing machines are rarely good value. The insurer sets the terms knowing the statistics are in their favour. Cover is typically adequate in the first five years but degrades significantly after that – often to the point where they will scrap rather than repair the machine. Many expensive faults are either excluded or hit the repair cap. The money is often better spent choosing a higher quality machine or a brand with a longer free guarantee.
Before buying an extended warranty on a washing machine, it is worth understanding how these products are structured and what they actually cover – particularly in the later years of the policy. The reality is considerably less reassuring than the marketing.
1. An Extended Warranty Is a Bet – and the Odds Favour the House
An extended warranty is an insurance product. You are betting your appliance will break down often enough and expensively enough to make the premiums worthwhile. The insurer accepts that bet with full access to reliability statistics and average repair cost data – knowing the odds are comfortably in their favour. Extended warranties became so profitable that some retailers relied on them almost exclusively for margin, leading to an investigation by the Office of Fair Trading.
Consumer advice has consistently turned against extended warranties since that investigation. If they were a good deal for the buyer on average, they would not be commercially viable for the seller.
2. Cover Degrades Significantly After Five Years
The most important fact about extended warranty cover on washing machines is what happens after the fifth year. Most policies do not continue to provide full cover indefinitely.
| Machine age | What typically happens | Practical implication |
|---|---|---|
| Under 5 years | Full repair covered, subject to exclusions | Adequate cover if the repair is not excluded |
| 5 to 6 years | Repaired if cost is under 50% of cheapest replacement. If over, machine is scrapped and you pay 50% of replacement cost | A £250 machine – any repair over £125 results in scrapping and a £125+ contribution from you |
| 6 to 7 years | Insurer contributes 40% toward replacement, you pay 60% | Significant out-of-pocket cost even when successfully claiming |
| Over 7 years | Insurer contributes only 30% toward replacement, you pay 70% plus delivery | 30% of the cheapest available replacement rarely covers the cost of a decent machine – and the warranty is then cancelled |
Millions of people pay for extended warranty cover without realising the level of protection has degraded to the point where it provides little practical value. The premiums continue regardless of how limited the cover has become.
3. The Faults You Most Need Covering Are Often the Most Likely to Be Rejected
The expensive repairs – PCB replacement, motor failure, drum bearing failure, outer drum replacement – are precisely the ones most likely to hit the repair cost cap and trigger a scrapping decision rather than a repair. Cheap repairs are covered; expensive ones often are not.
This is compounded by the increasing prevalence of machines with sealed outer drums and drums that cannot be stripped down. A foreign object trapped under the drum of one of these machines may result in scrapping simply because the machine cannot be disassembled to retrieve it.
4. Exclusions Can Remove Much of the Protection
Common exclusions across many extended warranty policies include:
- “No fault found” – if the engineer attends and cannot reproduce the fault, the visit may not be covered
- Damage from objects left in pockets or foreign objects in the machine
- Misuse or failure to follow the instruction manual
- Normal wear and tear – policies that exclude this specifically will not cover many common faults including belts, seals, and other wear items
A policy excluding “normal wear and tear” can legitimately decline to cover a large proportion of repair requests on an older machine.
5. The Replacement Machine Is Not Your Choice
When a repair exceeds the cap and the machine is scrapped, the replacement is typically sourced by the warranty company from their own suppliers. It may not be the machine you would choose, and you are paying at least half its cost – with the warranty then cancelled, even if the policy has only recently been taken out.
6. Spare Parts Pricing Works Against Extended Warranty Value
Budget washing machines often have disproportionately expensive spare parts relative to the machine’s purchase price. This is not a coincidence – some manufacturers price parts to recover margin on low initial sale prices. An appliance bought for £266 may have a control board that costs £138. With fitting, that single repair could approach £200, triggering a scrapping decision on a machine insured for full cover.
The practical result for extended warranty holders
- Cheap washing machines have the most expensive spare parts relative to their value
- Those machines hit the repair cap the fastest
- The extended warranty pays out the least on the machines that need it most
- The premium continues regardless
7. Better Alternatives to an Extended Warranty
More effective ways to spend the warranty premium
- Buy a higher quality machine – the annual extended warranty premium put toward a better-quality machine at the point of purchase reduces the likelihood of expensive repairs in the first place. See our guide on which washing machine to buy
- Choose a brand with a longer free guarantee – some brands include 2, 3, 5, or even 10-year guarantees at no additional cost. See our 5 tips for buying an appliance
- Remember your statutory rights – the Consumer Rights Act 2015 provides protection for up to six years for goods of unsatisfactory quality, regardless of what any guarantee or warranty says. See our guide on consumer rights and faulty appliances
- Self-insure – put the equivalent of the annual warranty premium into savings. This builds a repair fund with no exclusions, no repair caps, and no scrapping decisions made by someone else
8. Extended Warranties Do Suit Some People
An extended warranty is not valueless for everyone. Some people value the peace of mind of knowing a repair call-out will be arranged without negotiation, particularly if they are not confident handling the consumer rights process directly. Some policies do pay out promptly and fairly in the first five years.
The key is understanding what you are actually buying. Read the terms and conditions before committing, pay particular attention to the wear and tear exclusion and the repair cost caps, and calculate what cover you would realistically have if the machine develops a fault at age six or seven. That calculation changes the picture significantly for most policies.
Paying more for a washing machine does not automatically mean getting a better quality machine – it often just means more features on the same quality chassis. If the goal is reducing long-term repair costs, buying a higher quality brand at a similar price is more effective than buying an extended warranty on a budget machine. See our guide on is a more expensive washing machine a better one?
Buying a New Machine Instead?
Related Guides
Free 5-Year Parts Guarantees – What They Actually CoverWhy a 5-year parts guarantee is not the same as a 5-year repair guarantee – and what you actually get.
Consumer Rights and Faulty AppliancesYour rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 – which applies regardless of any guarantee or warranty.
Out of Guarantee – Still Covered?How to make a claim under consumer rights law even after the manufacturer’s guarantee has expired.
5 Tips for Buying a New ApplianceWhat to look for when buying – including which brands offer the best free guarantees.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an extended warranty on a washing machine worth buying?
For most people, no. The cover is adequate in the first five years for minor faults, but degrades significantly after that. The expensive repairs – motor, PCB, drum bearings – are most likely to hit the repair cost cap and result in scrapping rather than fixing. The annual premium is often better invested toward a higher quality machine or saved as a self-insured repair fund.
What happens if the repair cost exceeds the warranty limit?
The machine is scrapped and the insurer offers a contribution toward a replacement sourced through their own suppliers. The contribution decreases with the machine’s age: 50% of replacement cost after year five, 40% after year six, and 30% after year seven. The warranty is then cancelled regardless of how long it has been active.
What faults are typically not covered by extended warranties?
Common exclusions include no-fault-found visits, damage from foreign objects left in pockets, misuse, and – critically – normal wear and tear. A policy with a wear and tear exclusion can legitimately decline belts, seals, and many other common components. Always check the specific exclusions before purchasing.
Are there alternatives to an extended warranty?
Yes. Buy a better quality machine at the outset – some brands offer two, three, five, or ten-year free guarantees. Alternatively, self-insure by saving the equivalent premium into a dedicated fund. Consumer rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 also provide protection for up to six years for goods of unsatisfactory quality, regardless of any warranty terms.
Do I have to wait in all day for an engineer?
If you are a paying customer free to choose your own repairer, most independent engineers and competitive repair companies will work around reasonable requests. If you are a captive customer – covered by a manufacturer guarantee or breakdown insurance – you have less flexibility, but it is always worth negotiating for a narrower time slot or asking the engineer to call ahead on the day.
Waiting in all day for an appliance engineer is one of the most commonly cited frustrations with appliance repair. Understanding why it happens and what options exist can help reduce the inconvenience.
Why Do Repair Companies Give All-Day Slots?
All-day appointment slots – typically 8am to 6pm – exist for logistical rather than indifferent reasons. Engineers covering large areas cannot always predict journey times accurately, and accommodating each customer’s specific preferred window would require significantly more engineers and more travel time, making each job commercially unviable.
Most competitive repair companies do offer AM (8am to 1pm) or PM (12pm to 6pm) slots as a compromise. The availability of these narrower slots varies by area and how busy the booking schedule is on a given day.
Independent and smaller companies
Local sole traders and small independent repair companies typically cover a smaller area and carry fewer jobs per day. They are generally better placed to accommodate specific requests – avoiding school pick-up times, giving a 2 to 3 hour window, or calling ahead on the day. It is always worth asking directly.
Manufacturer and insurance engineers
If the repair is covered by a manufacturer guarantee or a breakdown insurance policy, you may be required to use their designated repairer. This means you are effectively a captive customer with no ability to take your business elsewhere if the slots offered are inconvenient.
Are You a Captive Customer?
The distinction between a paying customer and a captive customer significantly affects how much leverage you have.
Paying customer – free choice of repairer
You can use any repairer you choose. If a company cannot accommodate reasonable requests, go elsewhere. Competitive repair companies that offer time-specific slots, call-ahead notifications, and a genuine choice of appointment time deserve the business. See our guide on manufacturer vs independent engineer – which is best?
Captive customer – under guarantee or insurance
If the appliance is under a manufacturer guarantee or a maintenance contract, you may have no choice of engineer. In this position, arguing for a better slot is possible but you are negotiating from a weak position. Some older contracts allowed use of an independent repairer with cost reimbursement – check your policy documentation carefully.
Practical Tips for Getting a Better Slot
-
Ask for an AM or PM slot at the time of booking. Even if not offered automatically, requesting a half-day slot is always worth doing. Availability varies but it costs nothing to ask, and being willing to wait a day or two longer can sometimes unlock a narrower window.
-
Ask for a call-ahead on the day. Request at booking that a note is added for the engineer to call or text when they know approximately what time they will arrive. An engineer who has planned their day’s route can often give a 1 to 2 hour indication by mid-morning. This allows you to get on with your day rather than being confined to the house from 8am.
-
Ask if the engineer can call the day before. Some engineers receive their job list a day in advance. A quick call the evening before cannot guarantee a precise time but can give a useful indication of whether you are likely to be a morning or afternoon job.
-
Negotiate around specific constraints. If there is a fixed commitment – school pick-up, a medical appointment, a specific unavoidable window – state it clearly at the time of booking and ask whether it can be noted for the engineer. Most engineers would rather know about a constraint in advance than arrive to find nobody home.
-
Check if the company uses a text or notification system. Many repair companies now operate automated SMS or app notifications that give a 1 to 2 hour predicted arrival window on the day, updating as the engineer’s schedule changes. Ask whether this is available when booking.
If you need a repair arranged quickly, see our guide on getting an immediate or same-day repair call-out.
Ready to Book?
Related Guides
Manufacturer or Independent Engineer – Which Is Best?The pros and cons of using the manufacturer’s own engineer versus an independent repair company.
Need Someone Quickly?Options for getting a faster repair appointment when a same-day or next-day visit is needed.
What Does No Call-Out Charge Mean?What repair companies mean by “no call-out charge” and how repair pricing actually works.
Should a Washing Machine Be Taken Away for Repairs?Whether it is reasonable for an engineer to take your machine away to repair it rather than fixing it in situ.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to wait in all day for an appliance engineer?
If you are a paying customer free to choose your repairer, no – you can take your business to a company that offers narrower time slots. If you are covered by a manufacturer guarantee or breakdown insurance and must use a specific engineer, you have less flexibility but can still negotiate for a call-ahead on the day or a half-day AM or PM slot. Be willing to wait a day or two longer for a better slot if necessary.
Can I ask the engineer to call me when they know what time they will arrive?
Yes, and it is worth asking for this at the time of booking. Request that a note is added for the engineer to call or text with an approximate time once they have planned their day’s route. Most engineers are happy to do this – it ensures the customer is home when they arrive and makes for a more straightforward visit. Some companies have automated SMS systems that do this without the need to ask.
What can I do if I am a captive customer and cannot avoid an all-day slot?
Negotiate rather than simply accept the slot as presented. Offer to wait an extra day or two in exchange for a half-day window. Ask whether a call-ahead on the day is possible. State any specific fixed constraints clearly at booking – an unavoidable commitment during a particular window – and ask whether it can be noted for the engineer. A direct conversation at the booking stage is more effective than trying to adjust things on the day.
Repair company want to charge if engineer can’t find fault
The threat of being charged when an engineer finds no fault is commonly written into guarantee terms and instruction manuals. It exists primarily to discourage unnecessary call-outs – not every fault will reproduce on the day of the visit. If you have a genuine intermittent fault, tell the repair company before the visit, document evidence on your phone, and do not pay a no-fault-found charge simply because the engineer did not observe the fault on the day.
Being told you may be charged if the engineer finds nothing wrong is one of the more frustrating aspects of booking a repair under guarantee. Understanding when a charge is justified – and when it is not – puts you in a much stronger position if this situation arises.
When a No-Fault-Found Charge Is Justified
The no-fault-found charge is not simply a way for companies to make money from customers. It exists because unnecessary call-outs are genuinely common and consume engineer time that could be spent on real repairs. A charge is reasonable in these circumstances:
- Calling out an engineer for a general check-up shortly before a guarantee expires – a guarantee does not cover inspection visits
- Calling out for a fault that occurred only once and has not recurred – intermittent faults that happen just once often resolve themselves
- A fault caused by user error or misuse rather than a machine fault – for example, a load that is too small to spin, or detergent placed in the wrong compartment
If your machine occasionally does not spin at the end of the cycle, check whether this is happening with very small loads or single items before calling an engineer. This is normal behaviour on most modern machines, not a fault. See our guide on washing machine won’t spin single items or small loads.
When a No-Fault-Found Charge Is Not Justified
A genuine intermittent fault exists even when an engineer cannot reproduce it on a single visit. Intermittent faults are notoriously difficult to catch – engineers understand this. The logic that “we didn’t find anything, therefore there is nothing wrong” is flawed, and standing firm on this point is entirely reasonable.
When booking the service call, make clear that the fault does not happen every time. This is on record before the engineer attends and makes it harder to justify a no-fault-found charge if nothing is observed on the day. An engineer who knows in advance that a fault is intermittent cannot reasonably claim its absence during the visit proves the machine is sound.
How to Protect Yourself Before the Engineer Visits
Record evidence on your phone
If the fault is intermittent, record it whenever it occurs. A short video showing an unusual noise, a leak, incorrect behaviour, or an error code on screen is difficult to dismiss. Show this to the engineer if they claim nothing is wrong and attempt to charge for the visit. A video is far more persuasive than a verbal description.
Note when and how often the fault occurs
Before the engineer attends, write down when the fault happens – which part of the cycle, under what conditions, how frequently, and how long it has been occurring. This demonstrates you have a documented pattern of behaviour rather than a vague complaint, and makes it harder to claim the machine is simply fine.
Be certain the fault is not caused by misuse
Before calling an engineer, check the instruction manual carefully. Many fault reports turn out to be normal machine behaviour or the result of an incorrect setting, programme choice, or loading mistake. An engineer who establishes the cause is user error has solid grounds to charge for the visit.
If the Engineer Claims No Fault and Wants to Charge
If you are confident there is a genuine fault and the engineer cannot reproduce it on the day, you have options beyond simply paying or refusing.
-
Do not pay immediately. State clearly that you are not willing to pay a no-fault-found charge for a fault you know exists, and that the visit has not resolved the problem. Most engineers would rather leave without a confrontation than escalate a dispute on the doorstep.
-
Ask what happens if the fault recurs. If an engineer is insisting on charging for no fault found, ask what compensation or remediation you would receive if the fault appears again after the visit. This shifts the dynamic and puts the claim that nothing is wrong to the test.
-
Escalate to the company rather than the engineer. Individual engineers often have limited discretion. Contact the repair company or manufacturer directly if a dispute cannot be resolved on the day.
-
Know your consumer rights. If the appliance is still under guarantee and a genuine fault exists, the company has an obligation to address it. A fault that continues after an engineer visit that found nothing is a reasonable basis for a complaint. See our guides on consumer rights and faulty appliances and claiming compensation from a repairer.
Need a Reliable Engineer?
Related Guides
What Does No Call-Out Charge Mean?What repair companies mean by this promise and how repair pricing actually works in practice.
Consumer Rights and Faulty AppliancesYour rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 when an appliance has a genuine fault.
Claiming Compensation From a RepairerHow to escalate a dispute with a retailer or repair company when a fault is not resolved.
Do I Have to Wait in All Day for an Engineer?Practical tips for negotiating a narrower appointment slot when booking a repair visit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a repair company charge me if the engineer finds nothing wrong?
They can attempt to, and the charge may be written into guarantee terms. Whether it is justified depends on whether there is a genuine intermittent fault or whether the visit was for a non-fault reason. For a genuine intermittent fault that did not reproduce during the visit, a no-fault-found charge is difficult to justify – particularly if you told the company at the time of booking that the fault was intermittent.
How do I prove I have an intermittent fault?
Video footage on a smartphone is the most effective evidence. Record the fault whenever it occurs – unusual noises, error codes, unexpected behaviour, or leaks. A short video showing the fault in action is far harder to dismiss than a verbal description. Present this to the engineer if they claim nothing is wrong.
What should I say when booking if the fault is intermittent?
State clearly that the fault does not happen every time and ask that this is noted on the booking. This establishes before the visit that the fault is known to be intermittent. It makes it significantly harder for a company to justify a no-fault-found charge if the engineer does not observe the fault on the day.
Is a guarantee transferable when you buy a second hand appliance?
Manufacturer guarantees on appliances are almost never transferable to a new owner when the appliance is sold second-hand. The guarantee is a contract between the manufacturer and the original purchaser – most manufacturers limit it explicitly to that person. This is legally permitted. Your consumer rights when buying second-hand are also significantly more limited than when buying new.
This is a common source of confusion when buying or selling appliances second-hand. The short answer is that manufacturers are generally not obliged to honour a guarantee for anyone other than the original purchaser, and most choose not to do so.
Are Appliance Guarantees Transferable?
In most cases, no. A manufacturer’s guarantee is an additional benefit provided voluntarily – there is no legal requirement for any product to come with a guarantee at all. Because it is an addition to statutory rights rather than a right in itself, the manufacturer can impose conditions on it, including restricting it to the original purchaser.
What manufacturers typically do
- Limit the guarantee to the original purchaser only
- Require proof of purchase from the original retailer
- Require registration in the original owner’s name
- Decline to honour the guarantee when an appliance changes hands
What is sometimes possible
- Some guarantees are explicitly transferable – always check the terms
- Building and home improvement guarantees (double glazing, for example) are sometimes designed to transfer with the property
- If the guarantee paperwork travels with the appliance and registration was not required, a manufacturer may still send an engineer – particularly within a short guarantee period – though this is discretionary
The argument that a guarantee should transfer – since the cost of the guarantee was built into the original price and the manufacturer’s commitment was already made and presumably reserved against – is commercially reasonable. But manufacturers are entitled to structure guarantee terms as they wish, and most choose to tie them to the original purchaser. Always check the guarantee terms before buying a second-hand appliance on the assumption that the guarantee transfers.
What Happens If a Seller Misrepresents a Transferable Guarantee?
If a second-hand appliance was advertised as coming with a manufacturer guarantee – and it turns out the guarantee is not transferable – you may have a claim against the seller under the principle that the item was not as described.
Bought via eBay or a marketplace
If the listing described the appliance as coming with a transferable guarantee and this turned out to be incorrect, the item was not as described. Most marketplace platforms have buyer protection for this scenario. eBay’s buyer protection policy covers items that do not match the seller’s description. Contact the platform’s resolution process rather than pursuing the seller directly in the first instance.
Private sale
When buying from a private individual, your consumer rights are more limited than when buying from a trader. However, you still have a right for the item to be as described. If the guarantee was a stated part of the deal and it does not exist, this may be a basis for a price reduction or refund claim. The small claims court is an option if the seller will not engage.
Your Consumer Rights When Buying Second-Hand
Buying a second-hand appliance from a private individual is significantly different from buying new. Consumer rights protections that apply to new purchases from traders do not fully apply to private sales.
| Scenario | Key rights |
|---|---|
| Buying new from a retailer | Full Consumer Rights Act 2015 protection – goods must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose, and as described. Up to 6 years to claim in England and Wales |
| Buying second-hand from a trader or dealer | Consumer Rights Act 2015 applies, but “satisfactory quality” takes account of the age and price paid. Some protection still exists |
| Buying second-hand from a private individual | Much more limited. The main right is that the item must be as described in the listing. If it breaks down after purchase through normal use, this is generally the buyer’s risk |
For full detail on consumer rights when buying second-hand, see our guide on consumer rights when buying a second-hand washing machine.
Related Consumer Rights Guides
Related Guides
Consumer Rights: Buying a Second-Hand Washing MachineFull guide to your rights when buying a used washing machine – from a private individual or a trader.
Consumer Rights and Faulty AppliancesYour rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 when an appliance fails – new and second-hand.
Out of Guarantee – Still Covered?How the Consumer Rights Act provides protection beyond the manufacturer’s guarantee period.
5-Year Parts Guarantees – What They Actually CoverWhy a 5-year parts guarantee is not the same as a 5-year full repair guarantee – and what you actually get.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a manufacturer refuse to honour a guarantee on a second-hand appliance?
Yes, and most do. A manufacturer’s guarantee is a voluntary additional benefit, not a legal requirement. The manufacturer can set conditions on it, including restricting it to the original purchaser. This is legal. Your statutory consumer rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 are separate from any guarantee and apply to the purchase transaction itself – which for a second-hand private sale offers more limited protection than a new purchase from a retailer.
The seller told me the guarantee was transferable – what can I do if the manufacturer won’t honour it?
If the guarantee was stated as transferable in the listing and this turns out to be incorrect, the appliance was not as described. For eBay purchases, use the platform’s buyer protection process – this is usually the most direct route. For private sales outside a marketplace, contact the seller directly first and, if they do not engage, consider whether the amount involved justifies a small claims court application. Document everything: the original listing, the seller’s representations, and the manufacturer’s refusal.
Are any appliance guarantees transferable?
Some are – but they are the exception rather than the rule. Always read the guarantee terms carefully before buying a second-hand appliance on the assumption that the guarantee transfers. If the terms do not explicitly state that the guarantee is transferable, assume it is not. Some building and home improvement guarantees (double glazing, structural warranties) are designed to transfer with the property, but appliance guarantees rarely follow this model.