Whitegoodshelp Whitegoodshelp Blog

White Goods Help Blog:

White goods appliance help, advice & special offer notifications plus news & commentary, from a repairman with 30 years in the trade.

About | Contact me |  Subscribe in a reader | Register (receive notification of new articles)


Which is best, a top loader or a front loader? (washing machine)

Front loading washing machines are very dominant in the UK and with good reason. A front-loading washing machine uses considerably less water (reportedly up to 60% less), it also uses less electricity and less detergent. They tend to wash better these days too, especially after the introduction of the eco-label awards for wash efficiency focussed manufacturer’s attention in this area.

A front loader is essential if it’s required to fit under the worktop. However, as top loaders can be made much slimmer than front loaders, as long as you don’t need to fit it under a worktop – or are prepared to drag it out – and you have a small width restriction it may be the best choice.

Top loaders have historically had a bigger wash capacity which is another reason some might have preferred one but these days front loading washing machines are available with extra large drum capacities of 6 7 or 8Kg and even bigger. ( Related: Looking at how much laundry will fit into larger drum capacity washing machine – 7Kg v 5Kg washing machine drum pictures | 8Kg drum wash load in wash basket and hanging on line )

One of the most common so-called advantages of a top loader is that you can add an item of laundry after it has commenced washing but I fail to see how this is a serious advantage. The idea of leaving items of laundry out of the wash and then desperately needing to add something later being a common problem just doesn’t wash with me (excuse the pun).

Which? don’t appear to be too impressed with top loaders either saying that none of the ones they tested were good enough to be a Best Buy. However, they don’t qualify this by saying how many they tested. ( Reviews of 194 washing machines including 25 top performing Best Buys – 30 day online trial offer available )

At the end of the day some people may just prefer a top loading washing machine but front loading washing machines are likely to remain the number one choice. It’s possible that top loading washing machines may be more reliable in general, they tend to have less electronics and have more basic mechanical parts, but the greater running costs of a top loader are likely to cancel this out.

Finally, as top loaders use much more water (which is bad) a possible advantage to this is that they may rinse more efficiently. If rinsing thoroughly is very important to you (more important than wash efficiency and running costs) then it may be worth looking into a top loader but rinsing would need to be of paramount importance to you ( Why can’t modern washing machines rinse properly? )

Written By - Washerhelp on September 20th, 2007 with 9 comments
__
Read More Articles on Washing Machines & Washer Dryers |  Subscribe | Please Report any broken links - pretty please :-)

Why not add your comment? click the comment link above or scroll down to the comments box

Research white goods appliances as well as most other consumer goods and issues and read the latest reviews and best buy recommendations. Which? Online offer a 1 monthy trial for £1 - Which? reviews of washing machines & appliances with top performing Best Buys and Don't Buys.

Related articles

 

9 Comments

Read the comments left below, please add your thoughts on the topic too. (Comment box at bottom of comments) | Subscribe to Comments feed | Subscribe to Articles feed

Anonymous
#1. September 21st, 2007, at 4:35 PM.


Do the front loading washing machines sold in the U.K. have mold problems causing the clothes to smell badly after the wash?

Washerhelp Andy(A.R.T)Trigg
#2. September 22nd, 2007, at 10:52 AM.


You might find the following article useful, which covers mould, and bad smells in washing machines. I would think the problem can occur with either type of washing machine.

Washing machine smells – causes of grease, slime and black mould inside washing machines

Keith Tunnicliff Keith Tunnicliff
#3. December 12th, 2007, at 1:29 PM.


You can use soap powder in a top loader but not in a front loading washing machine, thereby avoiding all the problems of allergic reactions AND no need for any fabric softener!

Washerhelp Washerhelp
#4. December 13th, 2007, at 11:56 AM.


Hello Keith. Is there a known difference between top loader (and twin tub) detergent compared to front loader detergent with regards to allergies? As far as I know the only difference is that front loader detergent has suppressants in it to prevent excessive foaming.

gamston gamston
#5. October 6th, 2008, at 6:17 PM.


i have a maytag top loader washing machine please can anyone recommend a wash powder that does not leave a white residue on dark garments. When in America this did not happen at all.

Washerhelp Washerhelp
#6. October 7th, 2008, at 11:46 AM.


Hello Gamston: White residue or steaks left on laundry can be caused by a number of factors. It’s unlikely to be the detergent itself at fault. Have a look at this article, hope it helps – Residual washing powder after washing

tariq tariq
#7. July 22nd, 2009, at 6:18 PM.


is manual washing is possible in top loading washing machine in case there is a water shortage?

Washerhelp Washerhelp
#8. July 22nd, 2009, at 7:07 PM.


I don’t think so tariq. They have pressure switches to control the water level just like front loading washing machines, so they aren’t likely to wash without the required level of water.

Trackback Mention from Circleofblue.org
#9. August 3rd, 2009, at 2:34 PM.

Peter Gleick: Get Rid of Your Clunker | Circle of Blue | WaterNews: evidence to support that either, and plenty of evidence to contrary, including Consumer Reports and other reviews. Can you ...

 

Leave your comment...

Add your comment on the above topic using the box below: Please make sure it's on topic, comments just asking for repair help can't be accepted.



Subscribe without commenting

You can use these XHTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .

All work © Copyright Whitegoodshelp 2007 - 2010 | Feel free to quote but please link to the source.