Baby badly burned by washing machine detergent

This is an unfortunate incident, the Daily Record is reporting that a 17-month-old child (Taylor Mills) has apparently been burned by the gel in a washing machine detergent Ariel Excel. A spokesman for Proctor & Gamble who make the detergent in question are reported to have said: “All our products are extensively researched and are safe to use as directed.”

I have no reason to disbelieve this, so I doubt a general warning about the detergent in question is necessarily. I’m assuming that this incident has happened because the detergent did not dissolve properly and even survived all the rinses. This can happen if the drum is overloaded as tablets or gel packets can become trapped inside folds of laundry and not dissolve properly if they have no room to move about during washing.

It’s too early to know the exact cause of this particular incident but the manufacturer’s suspicion is that the product was not used exactly as directed by the instructions. However, as I’ve commented before, manufacturers of any product should presumably design them in the full knowledge that instructions will not always be followed, and must make sure that this inevitable fact of life cannot result in any serious consequences (within reason). At the same time people do have a duty of care to follow instructions and manufactures shouldn’t necessarily be held responsible if people are negligent, so it’s probably for the courts to decide.

The warning is that particularly when washing children’s items you should make sure the washing machine is loaded correctly and not overloaded to such an extent that the whole mass of laundry just turns round in one big lump. In such situations the detergent has no room to dissolve properly and as this case highlights, some undissolved detergents can burn and could have serious consequences. Instructions on the packet should also be read and understood. It’s too easy to assume we don’t need to look at instructions for commonly used products but we should.

Don’t under-load either

The washing machine drum does need to be fully loaded in order to avoid under loading, which can result in out of balance spins, or more commonly these days (due to the out of balance detection software in most washing machines) a refusal to spin altogether. It also needs to be fully loaded in order to wash economically and cut down unnecessary loads. Tips on loading can be found in my Washerhelp article – Am I overloading my washing machine?

Overloading may not be relevant in this case

I’ve written this article because the case has prompted me to remind people about overloading and highlighted the potential for more serious consequences than poor wash results. However, I don’t mean to have decided that overloading was definitely the main factor in this case. I can only presume that the gel somehow got trapped inside the babies garment and did not dissolve. There is the potential for other causes that I have not thought of. Hopefully I will be able to update this article if further light is shone on the subject.

Baby badly burned by washing machine detergent (The Daily Record news article)

Share

Research white goods appliances online

Which? Laundry & cleaning | Which? Kitchen Appliances | Which? Best washing machine brands | Which? Best Buy washing machines | Which? washing machine reviews - Which? are a registered charity campaigning for consumers and advise on most other consumer goods and issues - Why take out a Which? trial - what's the catch?

Book appliance Repairs: Book washing machine (or other appliance) repair (List of repairers on Washerhelp.co.uk)

Comments

  1. avatar Oliver Shaw says:

    That is terrible from a large company like P&G. Poor child.

    This clearly shows that it has not been properly tested, it is human nature not to follow the instructions on the package, P&G should have made it fool proof!

    Also shows washers do not rinse properly!!!!!

    There again it is suppost to work in cold water (15 deg C) so how can such a thick gooey mass disolve in 15 C? I have a look at this product and saw how thick it was I would have tought that hot water would struggle to make it dissolve.

    Oliver.

  2. avatar Washerhelp says:

    I assume the tablet needs plenty of water washing over it to properly dissolve and therefore relies on people following instructions and not overloading. Everyone knows that can never be relied on though, we are all guilty of not thoroughly reading most instructions – particularly on common products we just assume don’t need any instructions.

    Maybe it’s even possible a tablet could survive a perfectly loaded wash if the tablet accidentally got wrapped up inside a garment and remained shielded from the force of the water throughout the wash. This is pure speculation though, I’m sure tests are being carried out.

  3. avatar Ross Patzelt says:

    Hi,
    Thanks for your advice on loading washing machines. I have been guilty of putting too much in and especially now we have a baby this blog has made me think twice.

    Many thanks
    Ross Patzelt from Norwich

After posting a comment it will be visible only to you (above this text) until moderated

Comments moderated for spam. Please keep on topic. Your email isn't published, or compulsory, but useful for comment update notifications or if I needed to contact you about a comment.

Tick box below & enter email to get notified of new comments